Introduction

The Vancouver Canucks are currently grappling with a pressing dilemma in their defensive lineup, specifically regarding the second pairing of Carson Soucy and Tyler Myers.

Current Performance Issues

This season, both players have struggled significantly, contributing to a series of defensive blunders that have left the team vulnerable. Their inability to effectively transition the puck out of the defensive zone and their lack of physicality in front of the net have resulted in frustrating outcomes, with the Canucks being outscored 13 to 5 in games where both Soucy and Myers are on the ice at 5-on-5. This significant minus-8 goal differential reflects poorly on their synergy as a pairing.

Statistically, they have the worst Corsi percentage out of the 50 NHL defense pairings who have played over 150 minutes together, sitting at a dismal 37.1%. With shot attempts leaning heavily in favor of their opponents (227 to 134), it underscores the pressing need for a turnaround in performance.

Additionally, the pair has been consistently exposed during penalty kills, with Myers and Soucy on the ice for numerous power-play goals against. This dipping performance contrasts sharply with their previous season, where they managed to outscore their opponents even when facing tough competition.

Coach’s Perspective

Canucks head coach Rick Tocchet acknowledges the dilemma, suggesting that while Myers has shown signs of improvement, Soucy's confidence seems to be wavering. Tocchet emphasized the need for Soucy to be more aggressive and involved in play to regain his form.

Potential Solutions

The question now is how the Canucks can rectify this situation. Here are several potential strategies:

1. Patience and Hope for Improvement

The Canucks may opt to remain patient, allowing Soucy and Myers some time to regain their old form. While simple, this strategy comes with risks, as the pair's continued underperformance could further harm the team's standing.

2. Trade for a Top-Four Defenseman

With trade rumors swirling, the Canucks are expected to explore acquiring a more reliable defenseman. They have set their sights on Pittsburgh Penguins’ Marcus Pettersson, who offers experience and a solid presence on the ice. However, caution must be exercised as he too has faced challenges this season.

3. Call Up a Young Defenseman

The Canucks could consider promoting one of their promising AHL defenseman, potentially giving them a shot at a top-four role. This is a gamble, but similar to how they’ve integrated younger forwards, it may benefit the defense.

4. Reconfigure Pairings

Halting the pairing of Soucy and Myers may also just be the answer. By redistributing them with other defensemen like Quinn Hughes and Filip Hronek, the Canucks may create matchups that improve the overall team performance.

5. Utilize Brännström’s Emerging Talent

Erik Brännström has been making a case for more ice time with his recent performances. Elevating him to play alongside Myers may decrease the defensive struggles the team has encountered.

6. Combine Attributes of Both Players

What if the Canucks could merge the styles of Soucy and Myers into a new hybrid defenseman? This 'Frankenstein' approach, while tongue-in-cheek, represents the core idea of balancing strengths and weaknesses in a creative way.

7. The Disney-inspired Solution

Alternatively, a more lighthearted, albeit whimsical, approach could be to boost Soucy and Myers’ confidence by concocting a trade story. Convincing both that they were desired by another team could flutter their egos and unlock suppressed potential.

8. Explore Free Agency

Lastly, with some notable free-agent defensemen still available, the Canucks might take a leap. While some options come with risks (like aging veterans), others might add a much-needed breath of fresh air to the lineup.

Conclusion

In summary, the Canucks are at a critical juncture concerning their second defensive pairing. Whether through strategic trades, call-ups, or reshuffling existing personnel, they must act decisively to rectify what has become an evident liability. The stakes are high, and the time for action is now!