Introduction

Just when you thought you had the Game of the Year (GOTY) 2024 locked down, Atlus has swooped in with a surprise contender. The highly anticipated *Metaphor: ReFantazio* has burst onto the scene, boasting an impressive 94 Metascore, tying it with Sony’s *Astro Bot* and the acclaimed *Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree* expansion for the highest score this year. However, this three-way race may not be as clear-cut as it appears.

GOTY Eligibility Complications

While *Shadow of the Erdtree* has received rave reviews, it complicates its nomination eligibility for GOTY due to its dependency on the base game, *Elden Ring*. As such, it may not be counted as a standalone title by many award boards. Hence, the real contest looks to be among *Astro Bot*, *Metaphor: ReFantazio*, and *Final Fantasy VII Rebirth*, which is also doing well with a commendable score of 92.

Other Contenders

Other contenders swirling in the mix include indie darlings like *Animal Well*, the quirky *Balatro* (a fan-favorite), and the ambitious *Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth*. Even *Helldivers 2*, with its mixed reviews, might land a nomination thanks to its impactful gameplay. On the flip side, despite its commercial success, *Black Myth: Wukong* may struggle to secure a nod, as the popularity of a title doesn’t always equate to critical acclaim.

Who Will Win GOTY?

So, what’s likely to take home the coveted GOTY title? Many speculate that *Astro Bot* has the edge, not just for its stellar platforming but also for its heartfelt homage to the legacy of PlayStation gaming. With 135 critic reviews under its belt, it’s earned its place in the spotlight. In addition, the mass appeal of *Astro Bot* could mean it garners more votes come award season.

Conclusion

After an impressive 2023 gaming year, it seemed 2024 might take a backseat. However, with *Metaphor: ReFantazio* joining the fray, the competition is heating up. The first two months of the year will be critical as fans and critics eagerly await the announcement of the GOTY winner at The Game Awards. Stay tuned to see which game will reign supreme! Don't forget to follow for more updates on your favorite titles!