Netflix's New Christmas Movie 'The Merry Gentleman' Hits No. 1 — Is It Worth the Hype?

Netflix has just unveiled its latest holiday flick, 'The Merry Gentleman,' and it has quickly climbed to the top of the streaming charts, claiming the coveted No. 1 spot. Previously, 'Hot Frosty' held this title, but it seems the festive charm of 'The Merry Gentleman' has captivated audiences enough to steal the spotlight.

As the movie streams, early online reviews are rolling in, revealing a rather mixed response. Some viewers are delighted by the all-male dance revue at the movie's center, while others find themselves less enthusiastic about its concept. Personally, after watching 'The Merry Gentleman,' I must admit it didn’t leave a lasting impression and felt somewhat forgettable. However, for fans of Hallmark-style romantic comedies, this film could provide a few chuckles.

What’s the Story Behind 'The Merry Gentleman'?

The plot centers around Ashley (played by Britt Robertson), an aspiring dancer in a big city who loses her job due to age. Disheartened, she returns home for a Christmas retreat, only to discover that her family's modest performing venue is sinking in debt. Determined to save the day, Ashley decides to put on an all-male Christmas revue and persuades the dashing local carpenter, Luke (Chad Michael Murray), to join in the fun. As they dance their way to fundraising success, a sweet romance unfolds between the two.

Who’s Raving and Who’s Ranting?

At present, 'The Merry Gentleman' lacks a Rotten Tomatoes score, but it has garnered seven reviews, with only two being favorable. This indicates the film might struggle to escape an unfavorable rating.

In one of the positive reviews, LeisureByte’s Archi Sengupta described it as “ridiculously goofy,” highlighting that the film's sultry moments are likely to keep viewers entertained during this Christmas season. Meanwhile, Sarah Musnicky from But Why Tho? commended its creative twist, pointing out that the all-male dance troupe adds a unique flair worthy of attention.

On the flip side, critics have offered stinging critiques. Guardian’s Benjamin Lee summarized the film as lacking any standout merits. “It’s hardly terrible, but in a landscape crowded with holiday films, it struggles to make a memorable impact,” he said. Similarly, indieWire’s Samantha Bergeson lamented that despite Murray and Robertson’s performances, the film didn’t evoke that quintessential holiday spirit.

Patrick Cremona from Radio Times echoed this sentiment, suggesting it might appeal to die-hard fans of the genre but remains just an entertaining notion rather than an exhilarating experience.

Should You Hit 'Play' on 'The Merry Gentleman'?

While 'The Merry Gentleman' might charm fans of kitschy holiday rom-coms, it didn’t completely captivate me. The chemistry between Robertson and Murray was palpable, but their relationship felt hurried, lacking the emotional weight that often marks the best holiday films.

Some moments veer into cringe territory, a factor often excused in Christmas rom-coms, yet the absence of genuine holiday magic makes this movie hard to recommend for frequent viewing. However, if you love indulging in a warm and light-hearted Christmas film, it could still be a fun watch — cozy and inviting for anyone trying to embrace the holiday spirit.

If 'The Merry Gentleman' doesn’t pique your interest, be sure to check out our guide to all 47 Hallmark Christmas movies or explore intense holiday thrillers to spice up your festive season.

Stream 'The Merry Gentleman' on Netflix now, and decide for yourself if it’s a festive treat or a merry misstep!