No Clear Favorite for Stanley Cup Glory

This year’s Stanley Cup playoffs are unlike any other, with no standout favorite emerging from the pack. The first round presents an intriguing dilemma, as several of the top contenders are set to clash.

An NHL executive noted, “This year’s playoffs hinge on matchups. In the East, Tampa and Florida are likely the best teams, but they face off in Round 1.” With some contenders facing easier paths through the playoffs, the 2025 postseason has become more unpredictable than ever.

Inside Insights: Anonymous Panel Evaluates Playoff Teams

To gauge the landscape, we brought together a panel of nine anonymous insiders, including an NHL general manager and eight high-ranking front office executives. They ranked all 16 playoff teams in tiers from 1 to 5 based on their playoff potential.

Understanding the Tiers

Here’s how the tiers break down:

**Tier 1:** Stanley Cup favorites (top 3-4 teams) **Tier 2:** Strong Cup contender (high-level teams just below the elite) **Tier 3:** Dark horse (solid teams with potential but notable weaknesses) **Tier 4:** Long shot (may win a round but not serious Cup contenders) **Tier 5:** First-round cannon fodder (lucky to be in the playoffs) Let’s dive into the rankings!

Tier 1 Contenders

Colorado Avalanche Average Rating: 1.2

The Avalanche led the pack with the highest average tier rating. Their midseason roster upgrades, including the addition of Brock Nelson and Charlie Coyle, have fortified their already potent lineup. Upgrades to goaltending and emotional boosts from Gabriel Landeskog's return only add to their formidable presence.

One executive remarked, “At their best, they’re fast and heavy. Their power play is excellent.” Yet, facing the Dallas Stars in the first round presents a significant challenge, making it a tightly contested series.

Florida Panthers Average Rating: 1.3

The Panthers boast a star-studded lineup and a robust defensive structure. While health concerns loom, particularly regarding key player Matthew Tkachuk, their playoff-readiness shines through a gritty playing style. An executive stated, “Florida is built for playoffs; their DNA is evident.” However, fatigue remains a crucial factor, as they've battled through back-to-back finals.

Tampa Bay Lightning Average Rating: 1.4

After being rated Tier 3 last year, Tampa is back in the conversation as a top contender. Their strategic offseason pickups and Andrei Vasilevskiy returning to elite form solidify their spot as a fearsome opponent. “With Vasilevskiy in net, they always have a shot,” noted one executive.

Tier 2 Strong Contenders

Dallas Stars Average Rating: 1.7

Initially garnering Tier 1 votes, the Stars saw their ranking drop due to injury concerns, notably with Miro Heiskanen. Despite doubts, their elite roster still earns them respect.

Vegas Golden Knights Average Rating: 1.8

Flying under the radar, the Golden Knights possess a well-rounded team with a solid blend of skill and size. Their reliable goaltending makes them a dark horse in these playoffs.

Toronto Maple Leafs Average Rating: 2.2

Despite some skepticism surrounding their playoff performance, the Leafs have enough firepower and improved defense to stay competitive. However, the pressure is on star forwards to deliver.

Winnipeg Jets Average Rating: 2.3

The Jets face mixed opinions heading into the playoffs, with concerns about injuries and reliance on goalie Connor Hellebuyck. Yet, there’s optimism about their potential if they can stay healthy.

Edmonton Oilers Average Rating: 2.3

While led by stars Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, concerns about overall depth and goaltending haunt the Oilers as they navigate the playoffs.

Los Angeles Kings Average Rating: 2.5

The Kings have seen positive momentum, with a strong home record bolstering their chances as they aim for a deeper playoff push.

Tier 3 Dark Horses

Carolina Hurricanes Average Rating: 2.9

Once seen as a serious contender, the Hurricanes now face questions around their depth and power play effectiveness.

Washington Capitals Average Rating: 3.0

Despite a strong regular season, many remain skeptical about the Capitals' playoff credibility, especially with concerns about goaltending.

Tier 4 Long Shots

St. Louis Blues Average Rating: 4.0

The Blues enter the playoffs hot but lack the overall star power to be seen as true Cup contenders.

Ottawa Senators Average Rating: 4.0

Having made the playoffs for the first time since 2017, the Senators have played without fear, though they remain viewed as underdogs.

Tier 5 First-Round Cannon Fodder

Minnesota Wild Average Rating: 4.9

With many calling for early exits, the Wild face significant uphill battles against top-tier teams.

Montreal Canadiens Average Rating: 4.9

The young Canadiens have some talent, but executives largely see their chances of success as slim.

As the playoffs commence, fans can anticipate thrilling matchups and surprises. Buckle up for an electrifying postseason!