Introduction

On Friday, a wave of 31 MLB players found themselves non-tendered as their clubs opted not to offer them contracts, throwing them into the free agency pool. Though they might not carry the star power associated with well-known free agents, history has shown that these non-tendered players can provide substantial value. Case in point: notable successes like Kevin Gausman, Carlos Rodon, and Cody Bellinger, who have all turned their careers around after being let go.

Historically, players are non-tendered due to performance issues, injuries, or both—a summary that often masks their potential for recovery and contributions in the right environment. The Toronto Blue Jays aim to bolster their roster by simultaneously engaging in high-end free agency while keeping an eye out for these cost-effective talents to fill gaps and enhance depth.

With the Blue Jays primarily in need of bullpen support and left field or third base options, here are six non-tendered players—three relievers and three position players—who could make a significant impact in Toronto.

LHP Hoby Milner

Milner's past season was riddled with misfortune, as reflected in his 4.73 ERA, which stands in stark contrast to his more favorable metrics of a 3.15 xERA and a 3.14 FIP. Despite these challenges, he maintained a stellar barrel rate and groundball rate, granting hope for a rebound. His ability to induce weak contact makes him an intriguing multi-inning option for the Blue Jays. Signing him for around $1.5 million could yield considerable value, especially if he regains his previous form.

RHP Kyle Finnegan

Surprisingly non-tendered after saving 38 games and earning an All-Star nod, Finnegan possesses a power arm with a fastball reaching 99 mph and a repertoire that includes a diving splitter. However, despite his closing experience, he contended with challenges that may have influenced the Nationals' decision. If the Blue Jays can harness his capabilities and fine-tune his fastball execution, Finnegan could quickly become a cornerstone in their late-game strategy.

RHP Jacob Webb

With a solid 3.34 ERA across two seasons, Webb’s impressive strikeout numbers come with notable red flags—namely, his above-average walk rate and an elbow injury that sidelined him. However, with the Blue Jays' player development approach, there's potential for Webb to refine his command. His unique pitching arsenal, particularly his effective changeup, gives him the tools to thrive in a medium-leverage role at a minimal cost of about $1 million.

OF Austin Hays

After an injury-plagued 2024 season, Hays’ numbers dipped significantly. However, prior to that slump, he showcased above-average hitting ability alongside a strong defensive presence in the outfield. The Blue Jays could optimize his strengths by using him as a platoon player, particularly against lefties, and offer him a chance to rebound in 2025.

OF Mike Tauchman

Tauchman's transition to an effective player was first noted with the Yankees and has since continued with the Cubs. Although his power may have waned, his on-base skills remain impressive, boasting a 92nd percentile chase rate. The veteran could provide depth as a lefty hitter in the outfield, particularly with Varsho’s expected absence early in the season.

IF Josh Rojas

Rojas embodies versatility; he has played multiple infield and outfield positions throughout his career, making him a valuable asset for any team. After a dip in production, he still shows potential with prior serviceable hitting, strong defense, and base-running acumen that could translate well into a utility role with the Blue Jays.

Conclusion

As the Blue Jays continue crafting a competitive roster, these non-tendered players could be the pivotal pieces that fit seamlessly into the team dynamic, providing affordable yet impactful contributions as they gear up for the upcoming season. Keep your eyes on these potential acquisitions—they might just surprise everyone!