Nation

Whistleblower or Victim? Former AHS CEO Claims Health Minister LaGrange Fabricated Story to Justify Her Dismissal

2025-03-21

Author: Sophie

In a dramatic legal battle unfolding in Alberta, the former CEO of Alberta Health Services (AHS), Athana Mentzelopoulos, has accused Health Minister Adriana LaGrange of constructing a "false, vindictive, and malicious" narrative surrounding her dismissal. This alleged campaign aims to shift focus from troubling accusations of political interference in health contracts.

The unfolding saga begins with an 11-page court document filed by Mentzelopoulos in the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. In this document, she firmly contests LaGrange's claims, which suggest that her termination was merely due to poor job performance rather than her investigations into questionable contracting practices. According to Mentzelopoulos, these allegations serve as a "blatant" attempt to "smear" her reputation and damage her future career prospects.

Premier Danielle Smith’s administration has been embroiled in controversy following allegations from Mentzelopoulos's $1.7 million wrongful dismissal lawsuit. Central to her claims are allegations of political interference regarding procurement processes, particularly a questionable $70-million contract for Turkish medication and dealings related to chartered surgical facilities. The ongoing investigation has drawn the scrutiny of the RCMP and the Auditor-General, although as of now, these allegations remain unproven in court.

In her defense, LaGrange argued that Mentzelopoulos failed to advance the government’s agenda to restructure AHS into four separate entities. LaGrange alleged that Mentzelopoulos presented a "dramatic tale" to secure a larger financial pay-out, a claim Mentzelopoulos vehemently denies. She asserts that early discussions with LaGrange showed the minister had been pleased with her work performance, even stating, "I think you’ve done some phenomenal things in Alberta Health Services."

Mentzelopoulos has countered that the responsibility for the division of AHS lay with Alberta Health and not with her as the CEO. During her tenure, she faced challenges, including navigating a substantial budget shortfall and managing a backlog of surgical procedures, all while asserting she kept the AHS board informed of her investigative actions.

In a potentially explosive development, former chief of staff for Premier Smith, Marshall Smith, has found himself at the center of allegations made by Mentzelopoulos. She alleges that Evan Romanow, the deputy minister of mental health and addictions, expressed concerns that her investigation might reveal significant issues related to the ministry due to Smith's involvement, raising questions about the integrity of Alberta's addiction recovery initiatives.

Smith has responded vehemently, threatening legal action against Mentzelopoulos for what he labels as false and defamatory claims in her attempt to receive financial compensation from the government.

Since her removal from AHS on January 8, followed by the board's termination later that month, Mentzelopoulos has insisted that she maintained the board’s confidence while pursuing inquiries to potentially reclaim $49.2 million from MHCare Medical, the company linked to the controversial Turkish medication deal. Mentzelopoulos sought not only to secure the financial interests of AHS but also to ensure that future contracts could withstand scrutiny, given the troubling aspects that had recently come to light.

As the legal battle intensifies, the political ramifications extend beyond Alberta's health sector, potentially implicating further government officials and raising questions about transparency and accountability in public health management.

Stay tuned as this extraordinary story unfolds, shedding light on the murky waters of political influence in healthcare!