Introduction

As 2024 unfolds, the DIY home improvement trend continues to dominate social media feeds, but not all popular upgrades are welcome in the eyes of homeowners and experts. Many DIY enthusiasts are rethinking their beloved projects, with some designs and trends crossing the line from charming to cringe-worthy. Here’s a rundown of 24 DIY upgrades that people are increasingly calling into question.

1. Painted Cabinets

While a fresh coat of paint can breathe new life into older cabinetry, experts argue that attempting to salvage cheap, outdated cabinets can do more harm than good. A thick layer of paint can obscure the flaws but often results in an unattractive finish.

2. Limewashing Walls

The faux rustic charm of limewashing is under fire for being sloppy and less durable. Critics advocate for classic paint choices that won't look outdated as trends change—and believe that simplicity is often the best route.

3. Aesthetic-Only Fixtures

Homeowners are reminded that choosing glamorous fixtures without considering their maintenance is a recipe for trouble. High-care items look stunning but can become burdensome for daily upkeep.

4. Stock Tank Pools

They're cheaper and trendy, but potential owners should proceed with caution. Stock tank pools often lead to leaks and can disappoint when their size lets you down—definitely not a family-friendly investment.

5. Peel-and-Stick Tiles

Though convenient, many find the quality and aesthetics of plastic or vinyl tiles lacking. Traditional tiles, while more labor-intensive, often lead to better results and longevity.

6. Bold Wallpapered Powder Rooms

These daring choices can make spaces feel claustrophobic, especially with busy prints that aren't likely to age well. Simpler paint colors often provide a more timeless look.

7. Open Kitchen Cabinets

While airy concept, messy shelves often lead homeowners to regret ditching cabinet doors. Out of sight can mean out of mind, making it hard to maintain a tidy appearance.

8. Statement Front Doors in Suburbia

Unique doors can make a statement, but when combined with cookie-cutter homes, the results can appear mismatched and tacky. Residents are noting that cohesive aesthetics are often more appealing.

9. DIY Kitchen Cabinets

What seemed like a cost-effective DIY project can turn into a major marital headache. The investment of time and energy often outweighs the benefits and can lead to outcomes that feel cheap.

10. Color-Washed Walls

The trend of dark, oppressive colors in expansive homes is being questioned. Is it worth the aesthetic when the result resembles a dark cave? Many argue for lighter palettes to maintain an inviting feel.

11. Low-Quality Peel-and-Stick Wallpaper

While more durable options have emerged, true wallpaper remains the better choice for those wanting lasting quality in their designs.

12. Painted Brick

Opinions on painted brick are polarized, with many emphasizing the aesthetic shortcomings of DIY paint methods. Alternatives like stains or whitewashing are being promoted for a more refined appearance.

13. Strange Bathroom Colors

One renter shared an anecdote of a poorly executed design choice that resulted in a bizarre brown shade paired with reflective surfaces, leading to instant regret.

14. Sealing Asphalt Driveways

What seems like an annual chore can lead to a negative experience, leaving driveways streaky and dangerously slick in winter. Practicality trumps appearances here.

15. Bad Painting Techniques

The practice of layering paint over old paint tends to look tacky and wears poorly. Subpar results can diminish the appearance and longevity of surfaces that should be cherished.

16. Marble Contact Paper

This daring attempt at faux marble often falls flat, as the quality fails to mimic real stone. Those looking for elegant solutions are encouraged to fork over the cash for authentic materials.

17. Tongue-and-Groove and Shiplap

What seems like an easy DIY project often requires professional assistance to achieve the desired result, and many regret jumping on these bandwagons.

18. Gray Faux Wood Floors

New homebuyers are lamenting the lack of choices in finishes that come with new constructions. Often, these floors give off an undesirable, aged look instead of inviting warmth.

19. Faux Stone Materials

Homeowners express dissatisfaction with faux stone due to high costs and lackluster results. True stone can prove more cost-effective in the long run.

20. Poorly Painted Appliances

There's widespread frustration regarding DIY videos suggesting poorly executed paint jobs on quality appliances, diminishing their resale value and appearance.

21. Painting Antique Furniture

Altering classic pieces often leads to irreversible damage; many suggest preserving these treasures rather than turning them into unrecognizable items.

22. Overused Geometric Accent Walls

Once a trendy bold statement, geometric designs have become overplayed and are often regarded as tacky.

23. Hot Tubs

The honeymoon period can be short-lived as the reality of maintenance and troubleshooting settles in. Homeowners advise against this seemingly fun upgrade.

24. Edison String Lights

While charming for outdoor gatherings, these lights may be invasive for pets and can feel overdone as an outdoor décor staple.

Conclusion

As DIY trends shift, homeowners are encouraged to consider longevity, aesthetics, and practicality before diving into projects. What popular upgrade do you find overrated? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below for a lively discussion!