Disastrous Showing for Pochettino's USMNT as Canada Tops in Nations League

INGLEWOOD, Calif. -- In a shocking turn of events, the United States men's national team (USMNT) fell to Canada 2-1 in the third-place match of the 2025 Concacaf Nations League. This loss marked the team's second consecutive defeat in a tournament where they were once the reigning champions, having clinched their first three titles only to see their momentum falter dramatically.

Tani Oluwaseyi got the ball rolling for Canada, scoring in the 27th minute after a chaotic scramble near the goal. Just when it seemed the USMNT might buckle under pressure, Patrick Agyemang netted the equalizer eight minutes later, bringing temporary relief to the U.S. fans. However, the Canadians exhibited a more cohesive and potent offensive strategy throughout the match, even after losing their manager Jesse Marsch to a red card in the second half.

Ali Ahmed played a pivotal role in Canada’s comeback, delivering a brilliant pass to Jonathan David, who fired home from 14 yards out to restore Canada's lead just before the hour mark. This left interim coach Mauricio Pochettino with significant concerns as he prepares for the upcoming Concacaf Gold Cup, the final competitive tournament before the much-anticipated 2026 FIFA World Cup on home soil.

Despite some flashes of resilience, the USMNT's performance raised serious questions. Following a disheartening 1-0 loss to Panama, the team entered the match against Canada with low expectations. The early goal by Oluwaseyi could have derailed them, yet their determination surfaced next as a defiant Timothy Weah orchestrated an inspiring play to assist Agyemang in scoring an equalizer, demonstrating glimpses of potential.

However, the U.S. momentum was short-lived. Following David's goal, the team struggled to regain control, finishing the Nations League with a disappointing fourth-place ranking. Pochettino now faces an uphill battle in reshaping the squad ahead of the Gold Cup.

Defensive woes plagued the USMNT, with their back line notably lacking cohesion and composure. Mark McKenzie, who had been a steady performer, faltered under pressure, contributing to Canada's goal-scoring opportunities. Pochettino's hopes for a reliable defensive unit seem far-fetched as key players like Cameron Carter-Vickers and Joe Scally failed to impress.

The form of Christian Pulisic, who has enjoyed a stellar season with AC Milan—scoring 15 goals and ranking among the top scorers in USMNT history—fell flat during this tournament. Against Canada, he managed to complete only seven passes out of 12 attempts, leaving fans and analysts wondering if fatigue is beginning to take its toll. With essential matches looming, Pochettino must devise a strategy to rejuvenate Pulisic amid mounting expectations.

On the brighter side for Canada, they secured back-to-back victories against the U.S., underscoring a shift in power dynamics within North American soccer. Their two recent wins, including a friendly last year, illustrate a growing parity in the region’s competition.

Despite the absences of stars like Alphonso Davies, who suffered an injury early in the match, and coach Marsch’s red card, Canada pressed on triumphantly. Their ability to respond to adversity was evident, as seen in their swift recovery after Davies' departure and Marsch's suspension.

In terms of promising talent, Diego Luna showcased his capabilities, effectively delivering an assist to Agyemang and exhibiting a commendable urgency that Pochettino craves in his lineup. As the team prepares for the upcoming Gold Cup, Luna's performance solidifies his spot as a contender for increased playing time.

In conclusion, the U.S.'s disappointing Nations League run leaves much to be desired, forcing Pochettino to confront significant challenges in the run-up to an essential summer ahead. Can the USMNT bounce back, or will they continue to struggle on the path to the World Cup?