In a surprising twist, Atlus has thrown its hat into the ring for Game of the Year (GOTY) 2024 with the release of “Metaphor: ReFantazio.” After a year dominated by standout titles, this late entry has sparked an exciting three-way battle for the coveted award.

Currently boasting an impressive Metascore of 94, “Metaphor: ReFantazio” is tied for the highest score of the year alongside Sony’s “Astro Bot” and the “Shadow of the Erdtree” expansion for “Elden Ring.” However, the competition is more nuanced than it appears, as many outlets may not consider the “Shadow of the Erdtree” as a standalone title due to its reliance on the original “Elden Ring” experience.

As it stands, the primary contenders for GOTY seem to be “Astro Bot,” “Metaphor: ReFantazio,” and “Final Fantasy VII Rebirth,” which currently holds a stellar score of 92. Other notable titles that could potentially make the shortlist include “Animal Well,” “Balatro,” and “Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth.” Despite its strong sales, “Black Myth: Wukong” may not secure a nomination; popularity doesn’t always equate to critical acclaim, and there are simply many exciting games vying for recognition this year.

But which title has the best prospects for victory? “Astro Bot” stands out due to its quality and its homage to decades of PlayStation heritage, resonating deeply with both fans and critics. With 135 reviews securing its steady 94 Metascore, it’s a solid contender. On the other hand, “Final Fantasy VII Rebirth” has garnered 151 reviews, making it a strong rival that can’t be easily dismissed.

Initially, it seemed like 2024 might be less impressive than its predecessor; however, the landscape is proving far more competitive than anticipated as “Metaphor: ReFantazio” joins the fray. As we approach the final months of the year, speculation grows about which game will claim the top honor at The Game Awards.

Stay tuned for further updates on this thrilling race to find out who will take home the title of Game of the Year!