New Idol Group ‘cosmosy’ Faces Harsh Criticism

On April 11, 2025, the highly anticipated idol group cosmosy made their grand entrance on Music Bank in South Korea, kicking off their journey as a promising new act. The group is comprised of four Japanese members—Kamion, Dehana, Himesha, and A'mei—who were meticulously selected to embody characters from the wildly popular manga Cosmosy, which has captivated over 50 million readers globally.

These girls, described as magical warriors from the manga, are not only stepping into the shoes of their comic counterparts but are also set to star in an upcoming live-action film entitled ‘cosmosy ~ the a(e)nd of the world ~.’ This film, targeted at both loyal fans and fresh audiences, will explore their extraordinary quest to save the universe while balancing their idol personas.

Controversy Brews Before Major Debut

Despite their intriguing premise, cosmosy has encountered significant backlash, particularly due to their association with BLACKPINK’s creative director. Many critics accuse the group of mimicking existing K-Pop concepts rather than establishing a unique identity.

‘Lucky One’ Performance Sparks Outrage

Their debut performance of 'Lucky One' on Music Bank fell flat with K-Pop enthusiasts, who took to social media to express their disappointment. Users on platforms like theqoo were vocal about the perceived lack of effort in the group's styling, with comments ranging from disbelief to outright mockery.

Comments included harsh critiques, such as: - “It's not even a full-on costume; it’s half-a*sed, and that just makes it weirder.” - “If you’re going with this concept, you need to invest more.” - “This looks more like a comedy skit than a music performance.”

Many viewers noted that the group's hair and makeup made them look less like magical characters and more like a parody. One user even joked, 'Did they order those wigs from Temu?' while another couldn’t help but compare them to something out of a comedy sketch rather than a serious debut.

International Reception Still Mixed

Despite the harsh criticisms, there remains a sliver of intrigue surrounding cosmosy’s audacious concept. While they may be struggling domestically, the international audience appears more divided, with some expressing curiosity about the group’s unique approach. Whether they'll ultimately capture the hearts of fans or become a footnote in idol history remains to be seen.