Sport

NHL Teams' Preseason Predictions: A Quarter-Season Check-in

2024-11-21

Author: Kai

As we dive deeper into the 2024-25 NHL season, it's time to evaluate the bold predictions made before the puck dropped. With nearly a quarter of the season behind us, some forecasts have already come to fruition, while others seem increasingly improbable.
Atlantic Division Insights:
Boston Bruins:

Prediction: This will be Jim Montgomery's last season in Boston. Rating: **10** Given a disappointing start of 8-9-3, Montgomery was fired, mirroring trends seen with other Jack Adams winners under the management of Cam Neely. Notably, their current 31st ranking in offense and 28th in defense underscores the issues that led to Montgomery's departure. The team's performance is now under scrutiny as they grapple with the ramifications of cutting ties with a coach known for his defensive prowess.

Buffalo Sabres:

Prediction: The playoff drought ends. Rating: **5** While the Sabres are showing improvements in their defensive play and offensive output, they find themselves in a tough spot in the Eastern Conference. Their chances of snapping the postseason absence hinge on maintaining consistent performances and player development as they navigate a tight playoff race.

Detroit Red Wings:

Prediction: Hitting reverse in Motor City. Rating: **9** True to form, the Red Wings are struggling defensively, continuing to give up a concerning number of goals. Their recent offensive dip from 3.35 to 2.56 goals per game further afflicts their playoff aspirations, necessitating possible changes to shake up a stagnant lineup.

Florida Panthers:

Prediction: Regression, thy name is Sam Reinhart. Rating: **1** Reinhart's outstanding performance has proven critics wrong, as he exceeds expectations and contributes significantly to the Panthers’ offense with a robust goal-scoring rate.

Montreal Canadiens:

Prediction: Lane Hutson will be a Calder Trophy finalist. Rating: **8** Hutson has shown promise, leading rookie defensemen in points and holding his own on a challenging team. His evolving performance positions him as a serious contender for the Calder Trophy.

Ottawa Senators:

Prediction: Linus Ullmark will be one-and-done. Rating: **2** Ullmark’s commitment to the Senators with a four-year contract indicates a long-term arrangement, contrary to initial speculation regarding a brief tenure with the team.

Tampa Bay Lightning:

Prediction: Jake Guentzel scores 40 goals, at a minimum. Rating: **6** Though Guentzel is on pace to achieve 33 goals this season, collaborations with elite linemates hold promise for a scoring surge as the season progresses.

Toronto Maple Leafs:

Prediction: Mitch Marner re-signs with the Leafs. Rating: **8** Marner's impressive start to the season strengthens the case for a contract extension, as the Leafs aim for success while navigating trade speculation.

Metropolitan Division Highlights:
Carolina Hurricanes:

Prediction: Canes will miss the playoff cut. Rating: **0.28** With a stellar start, the Hurricanes are firmly in the playoff mix, defying preseason predictions by showcasing depth and performance.

Columbus Blue Jackets:

Prediction: Adam Fantilli has his breakout year. Rating: **4** Contrary to expectations, Fantilli's production has stalled, prompting concerns over whether he can deliver on the hope surrounding his rookie campaign.

New Jersey Devils:

Prediction: Devils will win the Eastern Conference. Rating: **7** The Devils show promise but face challenges with inconsistent goaltending as they aim to stabilize their pursuit of conference supremacy.

New York Islanders:

Prediction: Mathew Barzal will set a new career scoring mark. Rating: **5** An injury has hindered Barzal's progress, but there's still potential for a resurgence if he can return to full form.

New York Rangers:

Prediction: Rangers, Shesterkin get new deal done. Rating: **9** Negotiations are ongoing for Shesterkin, who remains a focal point for the Rangers’ success, with both sides expressing a desire to finalize a new contract.

Philadelphia Flyers:

Prediction: Jamie Drysdale stays healthy, breaks out. Rating: **1** Drysdale's struggles linger as injuries and lack of production continue to plague his development.

Pittsburgh Penguins:

Prediction: The power play finishes top 10. Rating: **7** Despite a rocky start to the season, improvements in special teams reflect the potential for the Penguins to rebound strategically.

Washington Capitals:

Prediction: Alex Ovechkin passes Wayne Gretzky. Rating: **8** Ovechkin's remarkable scoring start has been dampened by injury, casting uncertainty over his chase of Gretzky's record.

Central Division Snapshots:
Chicago Blackhawks:

Prediction: Seth Jones is traded. Rating: **4** Injury may limit trade prospects for Jones, whose situation remains unclear in the Blackhawks' rebuilding phase.

Colorado Avalanche:

Prediction: Gabriel Landeskog wins the Masterton Trophy. Rating: **6** Though Landeskog faces a challenging recovery journey, any return to the ice could earn him recognition for his perseverance and dedication.

Dallas Stars:

Prediction: Stars win the Western Conference. Rating: **7** The Stars' competitiveness remains evident as they navigate alongside other strong contenders in the Western Conference landscape.

Minnesota Wild:

Prediction: Jesper Wallstedt takes Filip Gustavsson's job. Rating: **1** Gustavsson has exceeded expectations, solidifying his role as the starting goaltender and outpacing Wallstedt’s anticipated rise.

Nashville Predators:

Prediction: Roman Josi wins the Norris Trophy. Rating: **2** Josi's performance dips raise questions about his candidacy amid a dismal team showing thus far.

St. Louis Blues:

Prediction: Doug Armstrong triumphs in offer sheet signings. Rating: **9** Armstrong’s bold moves are paying early dividends, with both players proving valuable despite their tumultuous backgrounds.

Utah Hockey Club:

Prediction: We'll just start calling them 'The Yetis.' Rating: **8** As the Utah Hockey Club continues to adjust, a nickname could foster a sense of identity amid a struggling debut season.

Winnipeg Jets:

Prediction: Connor Hellebuyck leads USA to 4 Nations Face-Off win. Rating: **9** Hellebuyck’s stellar play lays a strong foundation for Team USA’s pursuit of glory at the upcoming international tournament.

Pacific Division Takeaways:
Anaheim Ducks:

Prediction: Cam Fowler will be traded now, Trevor Zegras later. Rating: **6** With fluctuating performances, both players will see their futures hinge on team developments as the Ducks press forward.

Calgary Flames:

Prediction: The front office stubbornly refuses to tank. Rating: **10** The Flames are currently competing effectively, potentially hindering a needed rebuild in favor of a near-playoff finish.

Edmonton Oilers:

Prediction: Evander Kane will get the LTIR special. Rating: **7** Kane's lengthy recovery opens the door for salary cap manipulation, echoing past strategies seen in the league.

Los Angeles Kings:

Prediction: Quinton Byfield will break 70 points. Rating: **2** Byfield faces considerable challenge not only in hitting this target but in establishing himself as a scoring leader in his team’s lineup.

San Jose Sharks:

Prediction: Macklin Celebrini will win the Calder. Rating: **7** Despite injury setbacks, Celebrini’s potential for high-level play remains intact as he seeks to establish himself among top rookies.

Seattle Kraken:

Prediction: Shane Wright will quiet the critics. Rating: **1** Wright's ongoing struggles result in mounting criticism, leaving his future performance expectations in jeopardy.

Vancouver Canucks:

Prediction: Elias Pettersson will bounce back big. Rating: **5** As Pettersson begins to improve his numbers, he may yet fulfill his potential, bolstering the Canucks’ offensive effort.

Vegas Golden Knights:

Prediction: Golden Knights win a playoff round. Rating: **Pending** With strong performances showcasing playoff potential, the Golden Knights are on track for the postseason, but success will ultimately be determined during the playoffs.

As the season rolls on, these predictions will be continually re-evaluated, making the path ahead for each team exciting and unpredictable!